Outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has dropped his lawsuit accusing the NCAA of deceptive marketing of women's sports, ending a case that ran for nearly two years — and he did it days after losing his bid for the US Senate.
Paxton's office abandoned all claims in the suit without prejudice on Thursday, according to a district court filing in Lubbock County, Texas. The decision was first reported by Bloomberg Law. The case had spent most of its life in the 237th District Court in Lubbock, before Judge Les Hatch.
The lawsuit, filed in December 2024, said the NCAA falsely marketed events as women's athletics in violation of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, the state law that bars businesses from misleading buyers about goods or services that are not as advertised. Paxton accused the association of "engaging in false, deceptive, and misleading practices by marketing sporting events as 'women's' competitions only to then provide consumers with mixed sex competitions where biological males compete against biological females." He asked the court to bar the NCAA from allowing transgender athletes in women's events held in Texas or involving Texas teams, or to stop marketing the events as women's sports.
The case ended with no ruling on whether the NCAA misled anyone. The association changed its policy in 2025, voting to ban transgender women from women's sports without consulting its own medical experts, bringing its rules into line with President Trump's executive order threatening to block funding to colleges that allow transgender female athletes on women's teams.
The timing points to the change of leadership in the attorney general's office. Paxton lost his Senate race on November 3 to Democrat James Talarico, who beat him handily with 55 percent of the vote to his 43 percent — a historic result in a state where Democrats had not won a statewide race in more than 30 years. In the same election, Democrat Nathan Johnson defeated Republican Mayes Middleton to become the next attorney general. Johnson has pledged to end cases he inherits from Paxton that he considers politically motivated.
The NCAA lawsuit is not the only one being wound down. Paxton's office has dropped at least two other lawsuits since the November 3 election, including a suit seeking to shut down FIEL, a Houston immigrant-rights organization, and it ended an effort to dissolve Annunciation House, another immigrant-serving nonprofit. The Trump administration's Justice Department has moved to take over another Paxton lawsuit, the case against Planned Parenthood, after Texas voters chose a Democratic attorney general.
Paxton is set to leave office at the beginning of 2027, with less than two months left in his term. The lawsuits he filed were the signature of his tenure: aggressive, culture-war cases that made him a national figure among conservatives. The NCAA case was one of the most prominent — a novel use of consumer-protection law to fight a battle over transgender athletes.
It ends the way many such cases end: not with a verdict, but with a filing. The claims were dropped without prejudice, which means they could theoretically be filed again — but Johnson has given no sign that he plans to revive this one. The lawsuit that once aimed to bar transgender athletes from women's events in Texas now closes with the office that filed it about to change hands.



No comments:
Post a Comment