LEXINGTON, S.C. — Alex Murdaugh was back in a South Carolina courtroom on Friday, arguing not about the night his wife and son were killed, but about what the grand jury was told before it indicted him.
Defense attorney Jim Griffin asked Judge Debra McCaslin to throw out all four indictments — two murder charges and two weapons charges — saying lead investigator David Owen misled the grand jury that issued them in 2022.
Owen, a retired State Law Enforcement Division agent, told the grand jury that blood spatter had been found on a white T-shirt Murdaugh wore that night, the defense said. But an earlier state report found no blood stains on the shirt, and prosecutors never introduced any such evidence at Murdaugh's 2023 trial.
Griffin said the blood claim was the one piece of testimony that directly tied Murdaugh to the scene. "A phone call doesn't put him there. The video doesn't put him there," he said. "The blood from his murdered son sprang through the air — it's raining back on him — puts him there."
The defense also disputed Owen's claim that the unusual ammunition used to kill Paul Murdaugh — buckshot in one barrel, large birdshot in the other — was found in weapons across the family property.
Prosecutors called the blood claim "a single mistake," not bad faith, and said the case rests on much more: a kennel video Paul recorded that night, in which Alex Murdaugh's voice can be heard, contradicting his claim that he was nowhere near the kennels. Waters said the grand jury also heard about the family's financial troubles, missing guns and Murdaugh's theft schemes nearing exposure.
"This is what the agent understood at the time," Waters said. "And it's ultimately not something that would cause a substantial effect on the grand jury or cast grave doubt when we look at all the other evidence that was presented."
McCaslin did not rule after nearly two hours of arguments. She will issue a written decision by November 20, but one of her last questions hinted at her thinking: "If you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it all done and ready to go by April 5th?" Waters answered, "Your honor, I'm always working ahead."
A jury convicted Murdaugh in March 2023 of murdering his wife, Maggie, 52, and son Paul, 22, at the family's Moselle estate on June 7, 2021. The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned the convictions and life sentence on May 13, 2026, ruling that former clerk of court Becky Hill had improperly influenced jurors.
Murdaugh, 58, now awaits a retrial set for April 5, 2027, with jurors drawn from Sumter County. He remains in prison on separate financial-crime sentences, having admitted he was a thief, an insurance fraudster and a longtime opioid addict. He denies killing his family.
Even if McCaslin dismisses the indictments, the retrial is expected to proceed. Prosecutors say they could seek new indictments as early as next month, and the defense says it would not oppose that. "What we're asking, your honor, is to reboot — to go back to square one," Griffin said.
Owen retired abruptly in 2024, shortly after being named State Law Enforcement Officer of the Year. Last year a judge dismissed a separate murder case involving Owen after learning he had withheld information from prosecutors and defense lawyers.
Both sides now wait on McCaslin's order. If she sides with the defense, prosecutors head back to a grand jury. If not, the April retrial stays on track — and the question of what the first grand jury heard follows the case into its second trial.



No comments:
Post a Comment