A federal appeals court ruled on Friday that the U.S. House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it passed a $1.7 trillion government funding bill in 2022 while letting lawmakers vote by proxy instead of showing up in person.
The New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals voted 9-8 to uphold an injunction won by outgoing Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. The injunction blocks the federal government from enforcing one provision of that spending package — stronger legal protections for pregnant workers — against the state of Texas.
The case turns on a pandemic-era rule. During Covid-19, the House allowed members to record their presence by proxy to establish a quorum, the minimum number of lawmakers needed to conduct business. The House used that rule to pass the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, the sprawling end-of-year funding bill. It passed 225-201, with 226 members voting by proxy — more than half the chamber.
Judge Cory Wilson, appointed by President Donald Trump, wrote for the majority that the Constitution's Quorum Clause requires lawmakers to be physically present. "'Proxy presence' does not count," Wilson wrote, adding that while each chamber has wide discretion over its own rules, "the Quorum Clause's constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat." He was joined by Chief Judge Priscilla Richman Elrod and seven other judges.
The majority pointed to text, history and practice, arguing that the clause's "text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application" all indicate that members must be present for quorum purposes — as the Supreme Court held more than 125 years ago, and as Congress has done since the founding.
Judge James Graves, appointed by President Barack Obama, dissented, calling the ruling "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid." He argued the majority read a physical-presence requirement into the Quorum Clause that does not exist. Six judges joined his dissent, and Judge Catharina Haynes dissented separately, making the final vote 9-8.
The practical effect of the ruling is narrow for now. The court did not strike down the entire $1.7 trillion package. It only affirmed the lower court's order barring the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act — the provision Paxton challenged — against Texas. But the reasoning could reach further. The same logic could support challenges to other parts of the 2022 package, and legal experts expect the decision to be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The ruling reverses an August 2025 decision by a three-judge panel of the same court, which had found the proxy votes constitutional. The full court threw out that panel decision in January and reheard the case in May.
The original injunction came in February 2024 from U.S. District Judge James Wesley Hendrix in Texas. The advocacy group A Better Balance, which defended the law, says the decision effectively ends the pregnant-workers protections in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi — the three states the 5th Circuit covers, home to about 20 million women.
The House no longer uses proxy voting. The rule was dropped when Republicans took control of the chamber after the November 2022 elections, so the ruling does not change how Congress votes today. What it does is put a constitutional cloud over laws passed during the pandemic years — and hand the Supreme Court a question about how far a chamber's power to set its own rules can go.




No comments:
Post a Comment