Justice Clarence Thomas warned on Monday that states must not compel private citizens to speak the government's message, as the Supreme Court declined to hear a challenge to a California law requiring doctors to be taught about implicit bias.
The Court turned away the case, Khatibi v. Yip, on Monday, November 16, leaving in place a lower-court ruling that had upheld the California requirement. Thomas dissented, joined by Justice Samuel Alito. Justice Neil Gorsuch also noted that he would have granted the petition.
The case was brought by Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California physician, and the nonprofit group Do No Harm. They argued that California was forcing private instructors to communicate a viewpoint they did not share, in violation of the First Amendment.
At issue is a California law enacted in 2019 and implemented in 2022. It requires the state's licensed physicians to complete 50 hours of state-approved continuing medical education every two years, including instruction on implicit bias — the idea that unconscious attitudes can affect patient care.
Khatibi teaches continuing-education courses in California. She argued that the state gave instructors no real choice: to keep their courses approved, they had to discuss implicit bias in a way that affirmed the state's view that it causes disparities in health outcomes — turning private teachers into mouthpieces for the government.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed. In July 2025, it held that California-approved continuing-education courses count as government speech, because the state regulates the medical profession so extensively. Government speech receives different treatment under the First Amendment than private speech, so the requirement did not violate instructors' free-speech rights, the court concluded.
Thomas called that reasoning dangerous. He argued the appeals court had confused the government's power to regulate medical education with its power to speak through private individuals. The First Amendment, he wrote, protects Americans against government interference with their speech. The government can express its own opinions, he said, but that does not give it permission to require private citizens to repeat them.
"When, as here, the government does not issue its own messages but instead requires private speakers to communicate the government's viewpoint, the First Amendment applies," Thomas wrote. "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny. We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as 'a cover for censorship' or a cloak for compelled speech."
Thomas warned the logic would not stop at medicine: if heavy regulation is enough to turn private instructors' words into government speech, the same reasoning could reach other licensed fields, including legal education.
The refusal does not settle the constitutional question: the Ninth Circuit ruling and the California mandate stand, but whether the requirement violates the First Amendment remains open.
Thomas filed a second writing on the same orders list. In Novotny v. Moore, the Court declined to hear a challenge to a Maryland law barring licensed gun owners from carrying concealed firearms in places such as schools, mass transit and bars. There, Thomas filed a statement respecting the denial and said he agreed with the Court's decision not to grant the petition — willing to dissent loudly when he believes the justices are ducking a constitutional question, and willing to step aside when the case is not the right vehicle to answer it.
For now, the requirement stands. But Thomas's warning that the government-speech doctrine must not become a cover for compelled speech has put the issue squarely on the record for the next time it reaches the Court.



No comments:
Post a Comment