World News

Sports

Post Page Advertisement [Top]

Advertisement
PoliticsUS News

Federal Judge Throws Out Rule That Would Have Put a Four-Year Clock on Foreign Student Visas

A federal judge in Boston on Monday struck down a Trump administration rule that would have put a four-year expiration date on foreign student visas, ending a legal fight that had left hundreds of thousands of international students unsure how long they could stay in the United States.


U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV ruled that the Department of Homeland Security rule was "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law," and set it aside in full under the Administrative Procedure Act. The decision, issued November 16, granted summary judgment to the coalition of universities, unions and education groups that challenged the rule, and denied the government's own motion for summary judgment.


The rule, published by DHS on July 17, would have ended a system called "duration of status" that has governed international students for decades. Under that system, students on F-1 visas can stay in the country for as long as they are enrolled and making progress toward a degree. The new rule would have replaced it with a fixed admission period of no more than four years, after which students — along with J-1 exchange visitors and I-visa foreign journalists — would have had to apply to the government for an extension to stay.


It never took effect. Saylor put the rule on hold on September 14, one day before it was scheduled to start. Monday's ruling goes further: it vacates the rule entirely, so the old duration-of-status framework stays in place.


Saylor's order took aim at the reasoning behind the rule. He found that DHS had failed to weigh its costs against its benefits, had not justified the changes on the fraud and national security grounds it cited, had not considered less burdensome alternatives — including stronger use of the existing SEVIS tracking system — and had not adequately answered significant public comments. He also held that the rule's limits on academic study went beyond what Congress authorized for the F-1 student visa program, because they were not reasonably related to the purpose of the program.


The judge spelled out what the rule would have meant in practice. In his order, he said it would "prohibit foreign students from engaging in extended periods of study, such as those required for Ph.D. programs; prohibit them from obtaining joint degrees (and) prohibit them from changing their academic concentration."


The lawsuit, Presidents' Alliance v. DHS, was filed on August 18 in the District of Massachusetts. The plaintiffs included NAFSA: Association of International Educators, the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, the American Federation of Teachers, the Graduate Labor Organization, the United Auto Workers and The NewsGuild-CWA. In a statement Monday, the Presidents' Alliance said the ruling "preserves the longstanding D/S framework and prevents the rule's new fixed admission periods, extension-of-stay requirements, and restrictions on academic mobility from taking effect."


For students already in the United States, nothing changes for now. They remain under duration of status, the same as before the rule was published. What happens next is an open question. The government had already appealed Saylor's September order pausing the rule to the First Circuit, and that appeal was still pending when Monday's ruling came down. The order does not say whether the administration will appeal the final judgment, and DHS has not said publicly what it plans to do.


For now, that clock is gone. If the administration appeals, a higher court will decide whether it stays gone.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Bottom Ad [Post Page]

Advertisement