David Smith was at his wife's parents' house when the television told him what had happened to his sons.
A breaking news alert flashed across the screen: his wife, Susan Smith, had confessed to killing their two boys. For nine days he had sat beside her at news conferences, holding her hand, pleading for the children's safe return. He believed her story — that a man had carjacked her at a traffic light in Union, South Carolina, and driven off with Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, in the back seat. There was no such man.
"I found out she killed our children on live TV," he told CNN.
That was November 1994. Thirty-two years later, Smith is preparing to walk into a hearing room in Columbia and make the same argument he made two years ago: keep her in prison.
Susan Smith goes before the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons on Thursday, November 19. It is her second parole hearing since she became eligible for release. The first, in November 2024, ended with a unanimous vote to deny her. This time she needs at least five of the board's seven members to vote in her favor.
Smith, now 56, says the years have not softened anything. "It may be 32 years, but for me it's still like yesterday," he said in an interview with CNN published Sunday. "Thirty-two years hasn't changed the heartache." Asked what outcome he wants, he did not hesitate. "If I have a choice, I'd want her to stay in prison until she dies."
He will not be alone at the hearing. His wife, Tiffany Smith, their daughter and other relatives plan to stand beside him, as they did in 2024.
The case gripped the country in the fall of 1994. Susan Smith told police a stranger had taken her car with her sons inside. The story fell apart within days, and on November 3 she confessed. A jury convicted her in July 1995 of two counts of murder. She was sentenced to life in prison, with the possibility of parole after 30 years.
She is now 55 and held at Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina.
At the 2024 hearing, Susan Smith testified by video from prison. The board rejected her request unanimously. Of the 471 letters and emails the board received ahead of that hearing, only six supported her release. The prosecutor who tried the case, Tommy Pope, has also urged the board to keep her behind bars. Her lawyer, Tommy A. Thomas, declined to comment when reached by CNN.
David Smith was 23 when his sons died. He has since remarried and has two more children, Savannah, 25, and Nicolas, 22. He told CNN he still struggles as small details fade — the sound of their voices, the everyday things — and that strangers still leave toys at the lake where the boys died.
On Thursday, the board will hear testimony and review materials from her time in prison before voting. If it denies her again, she would have to wait until 2028 to apply a third time.
For David Smith, the hearing is not about the past. It is about the week ahead, and the one after that. "I really didn't think she would make it 30 years," he said, recalling what he told the board in 2024. He plans to be there for every hearing that follows, carrying a photograph of his sons.



No comments:
Post a Comment