WASHINGTON — The Navy relieved the commander of a destroyer deployed to the Middle East in late September. It did not tell the public. It did not tell Congress. The news surfaced only this week, when the ship sailed home.
Cmdr. Caitlin Cunningham was removed as commanding officer of the guided-missile destroyer USS Michael Murphy on September 27, the Navy confirmed to USNI News. The reason given was a "loss of confidence." No further explanation has been offered, and the Navy has not accused Cunningham of any specific wrongdoing in public.
"Loss of confidence" is the Navy's standard language when a superior decides a commander can no longer lead effectively. It does not by itself allege misconduct, and the service often gives no further detail. What is unusual here is not the language. It is the silence that followed.
Cunningham had taken command of the Pearl Harbor-based destroyer on October 24, 2025, less than a year before her removal. The Michael Murphy left Pearl Harbor on December 1, 2025, as part of the USS Abraham Lincoln carrier strike group, and spent the deployment supporting operations against Iran, including helping enforce the U.S. naval blockade in the Strait of Hormuz. The ship stayed in the region after the Lincoln group departed in August, and returned to Pearl Harbor on November 12 after a 346-day deployment.
The removal became public only when USNI News reported it on November 12, the same day the ship pulled back into port. A defense official told The Hill that Rear Adm. Todd F. Cimicata, commander of Carrier Strike Group 10, had relieved Cunningham. The Associated Press reported on November 13 that the Navy offered no public comment on the case even when asked.
Cunningham's case is not the only one. The AP reported that the Navy also removed the top three leaders of the nuclear-powered attack submarine USS South Dakota last month after the boat ran into something on the seabed — and again said nothing publicly and did not inform Congress. Rear Adm. Brian Monahan, the attending physician to Congress and the Supreme Court, has also left his post, according to the AP.
That silence is what drew the pushback. The Navy has long announced the removal of a commanding officer within days, as a matter of public record. Two senior House Democrats, Reps. Joe Courtney of Connecticut and Adam Smith of Washington, wrote to Navy leaders on November 12 demanding an explanation for why Congress was not told about the South Dakota and Michael Murphy removals.
The timing matters for another reason. The Senate Armed Services Committee is scheduled to hold a confirmation hearing on November 17 for Hung Cao, the nominee to be Navy secretary. The lawmakers' letter landed five days before that hearing, and the questions about who knew what — and when — are now part of it.
For now, the Navy has said little beyond confirming the relief. Cmdr. David Nicolas took over the Michael Murphy about a month before the ship came home and led it back to Pearl Harbor. Cunningham's next assignment has not been announced. What is known is that a commander was removed in the middle of a wartime deployment, the public heard nothing for six weeks, and Congress learned about it from the press. Lawmakers will want to know whether that was an oversight — or a new way of doing business.



No comments:
Post a Comment