Harry Shum Jr. danced two perfect routines on Tuesday night and still went home.
The actor and his professional partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated in the Season 35 semifinals of "Dancing With the Stars," one step short of the finale. They left the ballroom despite earning a perfect 60 out of 60 from the judges, tied for the highest score of the night.
It was the kind of result that leaves a studio audience gasping. Shum and Johnson opened with a paso doble to Rihanna's "We Found Love" and closed with a quickstep to "Valerie," the version from "Glee," the show that made Shum a household name. All three judges — Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli — gave both dances a 10. Two perfect 30s. And it still was not enough.
The show's scoring explains the shock. Judges' scores are combined with viewer votes, and the couple with the lowest combined total goes home. Shum and Johnson had the judges. They did not have the votes.
The clearest sign of how much the public vote mattered came from the bottom of the leaderboard. Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold finished last with the judges, scoring 48 out of 60 after a 24 for their jive and another 24 for their quickstep. They advanced anyway. TV Insider's breakdown of the scoring math suggested Wood may have pulled in the most viewer votes of the six remaining celebrities, enough to lift him past a perfect-score couple. The show does not release vote totals, so the exact numbers stay unknown.
Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov tied Shum and Johnson at the top with their own 60 out of 60, a salsa to "Bemba Colorá" and a Viennese waltz to "Dangerous Woman." Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas finished just behind them at 59, with a 30 for their samba and a 29 for a Viennese waltz set to Hozier's "Shrike." Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach scored 57, and Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik scored 55.
Five couples now head to the finale. Glenn and Pashkov, Higgins and Ballas, Frech and Karagach, Ali and Ravnik, and Wood and Arnold will all dance next Tuesday, November 24, in a three-hour live show on ABC and Disney+ starting at 8 p.m. Eastern. It streams the next day on Hulu.
Hosts Julianne Hough and Alfonso Ribeiro announced the result at the end of the night, after the six couples had each danced twice. Shum and Johnson were the last pair left standing with Frech and Karagach before the verdict came down.
Shum arrived at the semifinals as a frontrunner. He topped the leaderboard on premiere night and stayed near the top of it all season, one of the strongest dancers in a cast of 16. He is the 11th celebrity to leave this season, and his exit follows another surprise elimination the week before, when Jenna Dewan went home.
For a show built on the idea that the best dancing wins, Tuesday was a reminder of the other half of the formula. The judges can hand out all the 10s they want. The audience still gets the last word.



No comments:
Post a Comment