WASHINGTON — Sen. Ron Johnson started Wednesday by saying Social Security should be shut down. By lunchtime, he was telling his own committee he had misspoken.
Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, made the remark early Wednesday on Fox Business' "Big Money in the Morning," hours before he was scheduled to chair a hearing on the program's finances.
"At this point, there's really no way to fix Social Security," he told host Brian Brenberg. "It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it, you just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money."
Johnson was drawing on a memo he wrote himself, titled "Social Security: The Reality… a Legal Ponzi Scheme," which Fox News Digital first obtained ahead of the hearing. The memo argues that payroll taxes do not sit in personal retirement accounts but instead pay today's retirees, and that the government has misled workers about how the system works for decades.
By 11 a.m., when the hearing opened in the Dirksen Senate Office Building, the tone had changed. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon, the committee's top Democrat, told Johnson it was the first time in decades that a senior senator and Budget Committee chairman had said he would rather shut down Social Security than fix it.
Johnson conceded the television remark was poorly worded.
"I was talking about Ponzi schemes… imprecise statement I'll admit," he said, "but everything I've written, everything I've said, clearly I'm not proposing shutting down Social Security."
His stated proposal, laid out in the memo, is to change the law so benefits are not cut when the trust fund runs dry, then take on the federal debt and deficits. Democrats at the hearing pushed a different answer: make high earners pay more into the system.
The numbers behind the fight are stark. Johnson's memo projects a shortfall of roughly $511 billion by 2032 — about 21 percent of a projected $2.4 trillion federal deficit — when the retirement trust fund is expected to run dry.
The Social Security Trustees' 2026 report puts the depletion of the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance trust fund in the fourth quarter of 2032, one quarter earlier than the previous year's projection. After that point, payroll taxes still coming in would cover about 78 percent of scheduled benefits, a share that falls gradually to 62 percent by 2100. Pool the retirement and disability funds together and the money lasts until 2034, though that would take a change in the law.
The stakes reach more than 71 million people. As of July, the program supported over 54 million retired workers and 6 million disabled workers, paying an average monthly benefit of about $2,086 to retirees. In 2025 it paid out $1.6 trillion in benefits, with reserves of about $2.56 trillion left at year's end.
For a retiree collecting $2,000 a month, the automatic cut would mean about $1,560 — unless Congress acts first.
Johnson chairs the Budget Committee for two more months. Democrats take control in January, and the fight over what to do about 2032 is now theirs to inherit.
The hearing also heard from labor economist Kathryn Anne Edwards, who pushed back on the Ponzi scheme comparison and pointed to wage inequality as a driver of the system's strain. Her testimony drew a sharp exchange with Johnson, who grew defensive as she laid out her case.
Whether Johnson's walk-back settles the matter is an open question. His memo still calls the system a legal Ponzi scheme. What changed on Wednesday was the remedy he was willing to say out loud.




No comments:
Post a Comment